Emergency Contact Numbers

If you need to report a claim after hours, click here for help.

Log In


"Before I was insured with Cotgreave I was paying more than $1400 a year for my auto insurance. Now I am not only paying only $904 a year for the same car, but they doubled my coverage. That’s what I call a real savings."

Jeff Eluto
Holtsville, NY

Need Help?

Help is always a mouse click away with our advanced web site services. Or if you prefer, call us at:

Call (631) 981-5400

A Professional Insurance Company

The Cotgreave Insurance Agency is one of Long Island's largest insurance companies. There are other agencies who provide insurance, but none of them offer the SERVICE you can expect from the Cotgreave Insurance Agency. Our goal is to help you identify your insurance needs, and find the most cost-effective solutions available. Please take a look at the services we offer.

Identifying Your Needs

We are an independent insurance agency offering a wide variety of insurance and financial services and products. This allows us to represent several quality companies rated A+ by the Bests insurance guide. We can tailor an insurance program to fit your specific needs.

AARP Insurance for Home and Auto