Claims Reporting

Emergency Contact Numbers

If you need to report a claim after hours, click here for help.

Log In


"Before I was insured with Cotgreave I was paying more than $1400 a year for my auto insurance. Now I am not only paying only $904 a year for the same car, but they doubled my coverage. That’s what I call a real savings."

Jeff Eluto
Holtsville, NY

Need Help?

Help is always a mouse click away with our advanced web site services. Or if you prefer, call us at:

Call (631) 981-5400

Claims Reporting

If you have a claim emergency, check the following list to find your carrier's phone number.

Adirondack 1-877-248-0555
American Bankers 1-800-245-1505
Chubb 1-800-884-3770
Encompass 1-800-588-7400
Energi 1-978-531-1822
Fidelity Flood 1-800-725-9472
Hanover 1-800-628-0250
Harleysville (Nationwide) 1-888-560-9876
Hartford 1-800-280-0555
Interboro 1-516-248-1100
Kingstone 1-800-364-7045
Liberty Mutual/Peerless 1-800-362-0000
MAPFRE 1-800-562-4517
Merchants 1-888-644-6680
Mercury 1-800-987-6000
Metlife 1-800-854-6011
Metlife Flood 1-877-638-0022
MSA/Main Street America (National Grange) 1-877-425-2467 (Opt 3)
Narragansett 1-800-343-3375
National General (NatGen) 1-877-468-3466
NYCM (New York Central Mutual) 1-888-234-6926
NYPIUA (New York Property) 1-212-208-9700
ProSight / Tangram 1-800-774-2755 (Opt 1)
QBE/General Casualty 1-888-737-8256
Safeco 1-800-332-3226
Scottsdale 1-800-423-7675
Travelers (Personal) 1-800-252-4633
Travelers (Commercial) 1-800-238-6225
Travelers Flood 1-800-505-0193
US Coastal 1-866-482-5246
Utica National 1-800-216-1420
Utica First 1-800-456-4556
Zurich 1-800-987-3373