Emergency Contact Numbers

If you need to report a claim after hours, click here for help.

Log In


"Before I was insured with Cotgreave I was paying more than $1400 a year for my auto insurance. Now I am not only paying only $904 a year for the same car, but they doubled my coverage. That’s what I call a real savings."

Jeff Eluto
Holtsville, NY

Need Help?

Help is always a mouse click away with our advanced web site services. Or if you prefer, call us at:

Call (631) 981-5400


An Open Letter from The President

To our Clients:

For over 30 years we have insured thousands of customers throughout New York, New Jersey, and Connecticut. We are very proud of our history and heritage, but with that comes a responsibility. A responsibility to maintain the standard of client service established with our very first client. Delivering exceptional client service has been the mission of this company and will continue to be for years to come.

We accomplish this mission because of a dedicated, caring, and hard working group of employees. Without our loyal clients and employees, this company would not have been able to sustain success for over three decades. We are very proud of the many people who have worked here at our agency.

We will work diligently to earn your business, and equally so to keep it for years. We do this by utilizing our large stable of insurance companies to frequently shop your insurance making sure you have the best coverage at the most competitive price.

I appreciate the opportunity to serve you and I hope we'll see you in our office soon.


William Cotgreave

William C Cotgreave


Learn more: Skip Navigation Links

Agency Partners
Our Location