About Us

Emergency Contact Numbers

If you need to report a claim after hours, click here for help.

Log In


"Before I was insured with Cotgreave I was paying more than $1400 a year for my auto insurance. Now I am not only paying only $904 a year for the same car, but they doubled my coverage. That’s what I call a real savings."

Jeff Eluto
Holtsville, NY

Need Help?

Help is always a mouse click away with our advanced web site services. Or if you prefer, call us at:

Call (631) 981-5400

About Us

Located in the heart of Long Island, The Cotgreave Insurance Agency is an established leader in the insurance and financial industries. We service all forms of insurance throughout the tri-state area. We serve commercial and individual customers through an extensive worldwide insurance network consisting of several markets.

Our agency was built, and has survived so long, on the principal of providing superior customer service to our clients. As a locally owned agency we know you, your community and your business operation. As an independent insurance agency, we represent several insurance companies. Due to our premium volume with these carriers and our knowledgeable staff, we are able to negotiate for you the most competitive insurance solutions for our commercial and personal clients.

We are headquartered in Long Island, New York and we are licensed to write insurance everywhere in the United States.

Learn more: Skip Navigation Links

Agency Partners
Our Location